Grinding vs. full stump removal
Stump grinding uses a machine with a spinning cutting wheel to chew the stump down several inches below the surface. The roots stay in the ground and rot away over time. It's quick, it leaves a small footprint in the lawn, and it's what most homeowners need.
Full stump removal digs out the stump and the main root ball. It's slower, messier and more expensive, and it's usually only worth it when you're building, pouring a patio or planting a new tree in the exact same spot.
Why you can't just leave it at the curb
The Town of Manlius brush district doesn't collect stumps at all, and contractor brush isn't accepted at the Highway Department drop-off. Grinding solves this, because the stump turns into wood chips right where it stands.
What happens after grinding
- The grindings, a mix of wood chips and soil, can go back in the hole, be spread as mulch, or be hauled away. Ask which one your estimate includes.
- The spot will settle over the next few months as the leftover wood breaks down. Top it with soil and seed once it settles.
- If you plan to plant a new tree, pick a spot a few feet away from the old stump.
Before the grinder shows up
Underground lines should be marked before any digging or grinding. Your crew should call 811 (Dig Safely New York) to have utilities marked. Let them know about anything they won't find on that list too, like sprinkler lines, invisible dog fences or a buried propane line.
What it costs
This Old House puts stump removal in the Syracuse area at about $92 to $675, with an average around $429. Big stumps and hard-to-reach spots cost more. Several stumps in one visit are usually cheaper per stump. See the cost guide.
Call (315) 687-8301 or send the form with how many stumps you have, roughly how wide they are and where they are in the yard.